While I'm talking about Brandon Sanderson, I think I'll review his 2010 novel The Way of Kings.
Before I start, I'm going to tell you that this is the first of TEN books. That's a lot of books for one series. If you don't like Wheel of Time length epics, than you might not like this.
While this book got a lot of praise, I don't think it made a mark as much as his earlier Mistborn series.
The Way of Kings follows three characters: Kaladin Stormblessed, Dalinar Kholin, and Shallan. There are a lot of supporting characters, but none of them are as important as these three. Kaladin,who joined the army when his little brother was drafted, is sold into slavery by the noblemen who has a reputation as an honest and honorable man. He is placed into a bridge crew, a unit in the military that has the job of carrying bridges and putting them down so the soldiers can cross the chasms of the Shattered Plains. You can safely assume that since they're carrying bridges and putting them down before the soldiers arrive that they'll get shot at by the enemy, and this is exactly what happens. As he plans an escape, he turns the bridge crew with the highest casualty rate into the most effective.
Highprince Dalinar Kholin is one of the ten commanders of this army, who marched to war after the assassination of Dalinar's brother, the late king Gavilar. He sees visions of the past telling him to unite the other Highprinces before the Last Desolation comes against men.
Shallan is the daughter of a nobleman who recently died. She becomes apprentice to Jasnah Kholin, seeking not to learn, but to steal Jasnah's Soulcaster and use it to pay off her family's debts. I would go into more detail about the Soulcaster, but it takes a lot of explaining, and that's what the book is for. Besides, I think I've said enough.
The vast majority of the people that read this book loved it, me included. But there were a few who complained that at 1007 pages the book was too long and the overall story of the series didn't get anywhere.
This is true, but the story of the book by itself, without the overarching plot, was really good. It was kind of like a Robert Jordan book in that respect. The biggest strength of the book was Brandon's ability to show you not only the action-packed, serious parts, but the quiet, funny parts as well. One of the scenes I remember best is Kaladin and the rest of his bridge crew laughing around a campfire with a bowl of lousy soup in their hands. This is probably one of the reasons Brandon is such a good writer, period.
The thing that I thought subtracted from the book was that it says there's one prologue, but there are really four or five chapters that set up the story, and I didn't think that was necessary. I was also kind of irritated that there were about two hundred pages of flashbacks. It gave you more of the background story, but it really wasn't needed. Kaladin's situation could have been mentioned in maybe one flashback chapter, without detracting from the storyline of the book at all.
All in all, this book gets a 94%. It was good, but I thought it could have been better.
Critical Rants
A site that does exactly as its name implies: Critically ranting about whatever the author feels like. Most commonly these ramblings take the form of media reviews, but occasionally they bleed over into religious or political issues.
Saturday, January 28, 2012
Book Review- The Alloy of Law by Brandon Sanderson (2011)
I'm going to start off by giving the book its rating. I'm giving it an 81%, or a B-.
The Alloy of Law is the sequel to the popular Mistborn Trilogy. It isn't a direct sequel, since it happens three hundred years after the events of The Hero of Ages, so don't get confused.
The book is about nobleman Waxillium Ladrian, a descendant of Breeze from the original trilogy, who returns to the city of Elendel after spending twenty years as a lawman out in the Roughs, the Mistborn equivalent of the west. He is forced to become the head of his house after the death of his uncle and put away his guns. But he begins to follow the stories of a gang that has been stealing entire railroad cars, and when his fiancee is kidnapped, he must track them down to get her back.
This book is a lot like a combination of the original trilogy with Sherlock Holmes with a couple of John Wayne movies thrown in there. The Allomancer shootouts are awesome, and the verbal sparring between Wax and his sidekick Wayne is funny.
There were several complaints about this book, the biggest being that this was supposed to be a standalone but left us with a cliffhanger. I will admit that this bugged me, but it didn't subtract from my opinion of the book.
The biggest flaw in this novel is that the villain is a little cliche. This is very unusual of Brandon Sanderson, who has always given us solid, realistic characters in the past. But remember that this was originally going to be a short story that turned into a novel. I like to think of it as Brandon Sanderson goofing off for a little while in his universe before beginning work on the final volume of the Wheel of Time, A Memory of Light. It wasn't really a serious novel, just something to keep us occupied for a little while.
On the whole, I thought it was pretty good. Kind of like a movie in a popular series that wasn't as good as the others but still entertaining.
The Alloy of Law is the sequel to the popular Mistborn Trilogy. It isn't a direct sequel, since it happens three hundred years after the events of The Hero of Ages, so don't get confused.
The book is about nobleman Waxillium Ladrian, a descendant of Breeze from the original trilogy, who returns to the city of Elendel after spending twenty years as a lawman out in the Roughs, the Mistborn equivalent of the west. He is forced to become the head of his house after the death of his uncle and put away his guns. But he begins to follow the stories of a gang that has been stealing entire railroad cars, and when his fiancee is kidnapped, he must track them down to get her back.
This book is a lot like a combination of the original trilogy with Sherlock Holmes with a couple of John Wayne movies thrown in there. The Allomancer shootouts are awesome, and the verbal sparring between Wax and his sidekick Wayne is funny.
There were several complaints about this book, the biggest being that this was supposed to be a standalone but left us with a cliffhanger. I will admit that this bugged me, but it didn't subtract from my opinion of the book.
The biggest flaw in this novel is that the villain is a little cliche. This is very unusual of Brandon Sanderson, who has always given us solid, realistic characters in the past. But remember that this was originally going to be a short story that turned into a novel. I like to think of it as Brandon Sanderson goofing off for a little while in his universe before beginning work on the final volume of the Wheel of Time, A Memory of Light. It wasn't really a serious novel, just something to keep us occupied for a little while.
On the whole, I thought it was pretty good. Kind of like a movie in a popular series that wasn't as good as the others but still entertaining.
Wednesday, January 25, 2012
Music Review- Eclipse by Journey (2011)
Released: May 24, 2011
Genre: Rock
Length: 66:20
Label: Nomota LLC (United States)
Producer: Kevin Shirley
Tracklist:
City of Hope
Edge of the Moment
Chain of Love
Tantra (My Eyes Can See)
Anything is Possible
Resonate
She's a Mystery
Human Feel
Ritual
To Whom it May Concern
Someone
Venus
Eclipse is the second Journey album with Fillipino lead singer Arnel Pineda, who proved to the world in 2008's Revelation that he's a suitable replacement for one of Classic Rock's greatest vocalists: Steve Perry. While Revelation took us back to the Journey sound that dominated radios in the '80's, Eclipse is a completely different story. Pineda has a much bigger hand in collaboration than he did in 2008, and the other band members step back and focus on the overall sound of the album, instead of separate instrumental pieces. Eclipse takes all the familiar elements from the days of Steve Perry and mashes them with the elements from the early 1970's, when Gregg Rolie was lead singer and Neal Schon led the band with his progressive jazz-fusion rock records. Schon is definitely the main show on Eclipse, with loud, complicated but still catchy guitar riffs that blow the listener out of the water.
Eclipse opens with a bombardingly huge guitar solo that gives way to Arnel Pineda's vocals for "City of Hope." Pineda doesn't try nearly as hard to mimic Steve Perry in Eclipse, instead adopting some of his own vocal style that almost sounds like Dennis DeYoung. "Edge of the Moment" starts with a dark, cutting guitar solo and continues throughout the song. Schon and Pineda have the front of the stage for these first two songs while the other members stick to the back. "Chain of Love" opens with a piano melody from Jonathan Cain and some singing from Pineda that create a desperate mood before Schon cuts in with a grinding guitar melody. Cain and Pineda dominate the next song "Tantra (My Eyes Can See)," an almost cheesy ballad about God and spirituality. Schon takes center again for another motivational song, "Anything is Possible." "Resonate" sounds like a haunted house for the first forty seconds, until the dark guitar melody kicks in. After this point, Eclipse begins to fall back a little, with the mediocre "She's a Mystery" and the more pop-oriented "Ritual." "Human Feel" has a catchy drum rhythm that continues throughout the song, but at almost seven minutes it doesn't have enough melody and singing to keep it going. Eclipse closes with "To Whom it May Concern," a ballad about world peace, the very pop-oriented "Someone" (which would have fit in more on Revelation) and the guitar instrumental with the melody of "To Whom it May Concern" called "Venus," in which Neal Schon tries to destring his guitar with crazy solos and Deen Castranovo tries to beat through his drums.
The Good:
Unlike many of Journey's albums since Steve Perry left in the late '90's, where they tried to continue getting that old classic Journey sound, Eclipse abandons those efforts and mixes their older music back in the Gregg Rolie days with their later sounds of Steve Perry and Steve Augeri. Journey abandons all hope for airplay and popularity and goes for the music THEY want to do, which focuses a lot more on the overall sound of the band and music instead of having clearly distinguishable solo parts. Cain, Castranovo and Valory take a backseat while Pineda and Schon do most of the work, Schon in particular.
The Bad:
While the first half of the record was fantastic, the second half suffered a little from cheesy lyrics and very long guitar solos. Many fans will complain that the traditional sound of Journey is left in the dust, and that Schon seems to be the most important member here. While it is a guitar record, Pineda still has melodies to sing to, and Jonathan Cain adds some really nice background touches to the overall sound of the songs.
The Rating:
Four stars. After listening to this record often since I purchased it last December, I've grown very used to the music in it. Listeners should be warned beforehand that this isn't Journey's traditional sound, and that it takes at least five times listening to the entire album to get an honest opinion of it. Highly recommended for rock fans that especially like the guitar.
Top Songs:
City of Hope
Chain of Love
Resonate
Vodnik (upcoming novel)
Figured out how to insert pictures. Sorry, but this isn't a book review. This book doesn't come out until March, but I'm going to give whoever might be reading this a brief summary from the publisher.
In this YA fantasy, Tomas is a Roma teen who returns to Slovakia and discovers that the folk tale creatures he befriended as a young boy are more dangerous than he knew, and he must strike a bargain with Death to save his cousin's life.
That wasn't a very long (or entertaining) summary, so I'll give you another one from the author himself.
When Tomas and his family move back to Slovakia after a devastating fire, Tomas doesn’t remember the folktale creatures he befriended as a child.
But they remember him and his Roma family, and they’re not as friendly as they once were. Suddenly Tomas is in over his head, and he’ll have to strike a bargain with Death herself in order to put things right.
Amidst a backdrop of anti-Roma sentiment, he and his cousin must match wits with myths, and uncover the secrets of Tomas's past before their own futures become forfeit.
Sounds like the book will have a Percy Jackson type setting, but with a mythology that isn't generally known here in the states. But I'm not trying to compare it in any way to Percy Jackson. That's for you to decide.
It's coming out in March, so I'm pretty excited to read it and see how it is.
You can learn more about Vodnik at http://www.brycemoore.com/writing/vodnik/vodnik.html, or at the author's blog, http://brycesramblings.blogspot.com/. This is Bryce Moore's first novel, so I'm trying to help him out a bit and spread his name around a little. But from what I've seen in the Google search results it looks like there's a good number of people that know about this book.
Vodnik by Bryce Moore is being published by Tu books
You can also see it here at Amazon: http://www.amazon.com/Vodnik-Bryce-Moore/dp/1600608523
In this YA fantasy, Tomas is a Roma teen who returns to Slovakia and discovers that the folk tale creatures he befriended as a young boy are more dangerous than he knew, and he must strike a bargain with Death to save his cousin's life.
That wasn't a very long (or entertaining) summary, so I'll give you another one from the author himself.
When Tomas and his family move back to Slovakia after a devastating fire, Tomas doesn’t remember the folktale creatures he befriended as a child.
But they remember him and his Roma family, and they’re not as friendly as they once were. Suddenly Tomas is in over his head, and he’ll have to strike a bargain with Death herself in order to put things right.
Amidst a backdrop of anti-Roma sentiment, he and his cousin must match wits with myths, and uncover the secrets of Tomas's past before their own futures become forfeit.
Sounds like the book will have a Percy Jackson type setting, but with a mythology that isn't generally known here in the states. But I'm not trying to compare it in any way to Percy Jackson. That's for you to decide.
It's coming out in March, so I'm pretty excited to read it and see how it is.
You can learn more about Vodnik at http://www.brycemoore.com/writing/vodnik/vodnik.html, or at the author's blog, http://brycesramblings.blogspot.com/. This is Bryce Moore's first novel, so I'm trying to help him out a bit and spread his name around a little. But from what I've seen in the Google search results it looks like there's a good number of people that know about this book.
Vodnik by Bryce Moore is being published by Tu books
You can also see it here at Amazon: http://www.amazon.com/Vodnik-Bryce-Moore/dp/1600608523
First Blog Post
I am exactly what the name of this blog implies. A ranting critic. I'll try to keep my opinionated lectures to a minimum, but I can't guarantee that they won't pop up occasionally.
A question you probably have is what this ranting critic is going to be ranting about. I'm going to post reviews of all kinds of things, from books to movies to music albums. But books are going to be the ones I post about the most, with occasional movie reviews. The genres I'm going to be reviewing are primarily Sci-Fi and Fantasy, so if you don't like those genres than you probably won't like most of these posts.
That's pretty much all I've got to say right now. What a rambler I am. But I'm going to be posting my first couple of book reviews in the very near future, so don't be disappointed yet.
Eventually my book reviews will have pictures of the books, but I have to fiddle around with this for a while first
A question you probably have is what this ranting critic is going to be ranting about. I'm going to post reviews of all kinds of things, from books to movies to music albums. But books are going to be the ones I post about the most, with occasional movie reviews. The genres I'm going to be reviewing are primarily Sci-Fi and Fantasy, so if you don't like those genres than you probably won't like most of these posts.
That's pretty much all I've got to say right now. What a rambler I am. But I'm going to be posting my first couple of book reviews in the very near future, so don't be disappointed yet.
Eventually my book reviews will have pictures of the books, but I have to fiddle around with this for a while first
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)